Get Cases Direct To Your Inbox Totally FREE
MRCS Part B Questions

MRCS Part B Revision · Surgical pathology

Pneumothorax — MRCS Part B Surgical pathology

By Dr Richard Miller, MBChB FRCS · Reviewed

Pneumothorax is a surgical pathology station. Two of the seventeen examined stations in the MRCS Part B OSCE are surgical pathology. The surgical pathology stations ask you to reason from a specimen, a slide, a report or a vignette to a diagnosis, and then to say what it means for the patient in front of you.

What you need to know for the Pneumothorax station

A chest radiograph after trauma, used to cover pneumothorax in all its forms, then the flail chest and the pulmonary contusion beneath it.

Recognising it before the film

Chest pain and breathlessness after the injury, reduced expansion on one side, a hyper-resonant percussion note and absent breath sounds. Tension adds the signs of obstructed venous return: tachycardia, hypotension, distended neck veins, tracheal deviation away from the affected side, and a patient who is deteriorating in front of you. Tension is diagnosed clinically and treated before any radiograph.

Types

Spontaneous, either primary in a tall thin young smoker from a ruptured apical bleb, or secondary to lung disease such as emphysema, cystic fibrosis or pneumocystis pneumonia; traumatic, from a fractured rib, a stab or a needle; iatrogenic, after a central line, a pleural aspiration or a ventilator; open, when a chest wall wound larger than the trachea lets air in and out of the pleural space with every breath so the lung cannot inflate; and tension, when a flap of tissue acts as a valve so air enters the pleural space on inspiration and cannot leave. The pressure rises, the lung collapses, the mediastinum shifts, the great veins kink and cardiac output falls: it kills by obstructing venous return, not by loss of one lung.

Management

A tension pneumothorax is decompressed at once with a wide-bore cannula in the fourth or fifth intercostal space just in front of the mid-axillary line (or the second space in the mid-clavicular line, above the third rib, if the chest wall is thin), followed by a chest drain in the safe triangle. An open pneumothorax is covered with an occlusive dressing taped on three sides, so that air can escape but not enter, and a drain is placed away from the wound before the wound itself is closed. A traumatic pneumothorax is drained, and always before positive-pressure ventilation. A small primary spontaneous pneumothorax without breathlessness can be observed; a larger or symptomatic one is aspirated, and a drain is placed if that fails or the patient has lung disease. For recurrence, or a first episode in someone whose job or sport makes another dangerous, the options are video-assisted thoracoscopic bullectomy with pleurodesis (by abrasion, pleurectomy or talc) or, in the unfit, chemical pleurodesis through the drain.

Flail chest

Paradoxical movement of a segment of the chest wall, drawn in on inspiration and pushed out on expiration, means that two or more adjacent ribs are broken in two or more places so that the segment is no longer attached to the rest of the cage and follows the pressure in the pleural space rather than the movement of the wall. The radiograph shows the rib fractures, often with a haemothorax or pneumothorax, and the patchy shadowing of the contusion beneath. The segment itself matters less than the contused lung under it, which stiffens, shunts and fills with fluid over the next two days, so hypoxia worsens after admission; its consequences are pneumonia, ARDS and respiratory failure, and the risk is greatest in the elderly and in anyone with lung disease. Management is oxygen, good analgesia (an epidural or a paravertebral block, so the patient can breathe deeply and cough), careful fluids, physiotherapy, drainage of any air or blood, and ventilation with positive pressure if the patient tires. Operative fixation of the ribs shortens ventilation in selected patients.

Images from this station

Pneumothorax — MRCS Part B Surgical pathology

What are you asked at the Pneumothorax station?

The station runs to 15 questions over nine minutes. These are the questions as they are put to you; the model answers are in the question bank.

  1. Describe the radiograph
  2. How would you manage this patient?
  3. Prior to obtaining the above chest radiograph what signs and symptoms might have led you to suspect the diagnosis?
  4. Why is a tension pneumothorax an emergency?
  5. What other types of pneumothoraces do you know?
  6. Other than trauma what else can cause a pneumothorax?
  7. Had the patient in the scenario had an open chest wound creating an open pneumothorax how would your management have differed?
  8. How would you manage a spontaneous pneumothorax?
  9. What are the management options for patients with recurrent pneumothoraces?
  10. Had the patient also presented with paradoxical chest movements on the right side what might you suspect given the mechanism of injury?
  11. In a patient with a likely right-sided flail segment what does the above radiograph show?
    Pneumothorax — In a patient with a likely right-sided flail segment what does the above radiograph show?
  12. Why does a flail segment move paradoxically?

And 3 more at this station.

How is the surgical pathology station marked in MRCS Part B?

Like the anatomy stations, a surgical pathology station is marked out of 20 with all 20 marks going to clinical knowledge and its application. The second of the two may be a microbiology station.

FAQ

What does the Pneumothorax station ask?

It opens with "Describe the radiograph" and runs to 15 questions over nine minutes. Like the anatomy stations, a surgical pathology station is marked out of 20 with all 20 marks going to clinical knowledge and its application. The second of the two may be a microbiology station.

How many pathology stations are in MRCS Part B?

Two of the seventeen examined stations. The intercollegiate blueprint titles the second one surgical pathology and/or microbiology, so infection and antimicrobial topics appear here rather than in a station of their own.

How is the pathology station marked?

Out of 20, with every mark awarded for clinical knowledge and its application. There are no communication or professionalism marks available in it.

What should I revise for surgical pathology?

The general processes the syllabus names, inflammation, healing, neoplasia and infection, applied to the specimens and reports a surgical trainee meets. Candidates most often report malignancies and their mutations, inherited cancer syndromes, and obstructive jaundice.

How many stations are in the MRCS Part B OSCE?

Seventeen examined stations of nine minutes each, with a minute to read the task before each one. Two preparation stations and at least one rest station bring the circuit to about twenty, and the exam takes about three and a half hours.

What is the pass mark for MRCS Part B?

There is no published pass mark. The cut score is set separately for Applied Knowledge and Applied Skills, for each circuit, by borderline regression. Published pass rates across the 2024/25 diets ranged from 51% to 66%.

Can I fail a station and still pass?

Yes. There is no rule about how many stations you may fail: the cut score applies to your total mark in each component, so a weak station costs the marks you lost on it and strong stations elsewhere can make them back. Applied Knowledge and Applied Skills are passed separately and must both be passed at the same sitting, so a strong anatomy performance cannot rescue a weak communication one.

Dr Richard Miller, MBChB FRCS

Station summaries are reviewed against the current intercollegiate MRCS syllabus and the published marking blueprint. Guidance changes between diets: check the royal colleges' own pages before relying on a date, a fee or a threshold.

Practise this station

The question bank carries the model answer to every question above, with the rest of the surgical pathology stations.

More surgical pathology stations